Avoiding Common Mistakes When Writing Suspense

The Foundation of Effective Suspense Writing

Suspense is about creating uncertainty and tension. It keeps the reader turning pages because they want to know what happens next.

Writing suspense well requires careful planning. It is not about adding surprise after surprise. It is about giving the reader just enough information to feel the risk, but not enough to feel safe. If you want to write effective suspense, you need to avoid the most common mistakes that weaken this effect.

Suspense relies on timing, clarity, and control. A single misstep can break the tension. To write suspense that works, you must understand how to build it, how to maintain it, and when to release it.

Mistake 1: Revealing Too Much Too Soon

One of the most common mistakes in suspense writing is giving away the answers early. If the reader knows everything from the beginning, there is no reason to keep reading. Suspense depends on delay. You should hold back key information and reveal it slowly.

This does not mean you should be confusing or vague. The reader still needs a clear sense of what is at stake. But they do not need to know why, how, or when everything will happen. Ask yourself: What does the reader know now? What do they expect? What will surprise them?

Use small clues and let tension grow gradually. Give the reader enough to think something is wrong, but not enough to know exactly what.

Mistake 2: Adding Surprises Without Build-Up

A twist or sudden event can add to suspense, but only if it feels earned. If a surprise comes out of nowhere, it can confuse the reader or feel dishonest. Suspense is not just about what happens, but how it builds.

A good twist should feel like a piece of a puzzle falling into place. The reader might not see it coming, but once it happens, they should realise the signs were there all along. If your surprises do not have setup, they will not have impact.

Use foreshadowing, suggest hidden motives, or create a pattern that the twist can break. Make your surprises meaningful, not random.

Mistake 3: Flat or Passive Protagonists

Suspense stories need strong characters. If your main character does not act, change, or react, the reader loses interest. The character must make choices and face consequences. These decisions help create tension.

Your protagonist should have something to lose. They need a goal, a fear, or a secret. When you show what matters to them, the reader understands the stakes. This makes every danger feel more real.

Avoid making your character a passive observer. Even if they are unsure or afraid, they should take steps—right or wrong. This keeps the reader engaged in their journey.

Mistake 4: Lack of Clear Stakes

Suspense is not just about danger. It is about what is at risk. If the reader does not know what the character could lose, they will not feel the tension.

Every suspenseful moment should answer the question: What happens if this goes wrong?

Stakes can be physical (a life in danger), emotional (a relationship at risk), or internal (a loss of identity or purpose). The more specific the stakes, the better. Instead of saying “everything is at risk,” show what “everything” means to your character.

Clarify the stakes early, then raise them as the story continues. This keeps the pressure on the character and the reader.

Mistake 5: Confusing Suspense with Action

Suspense and action are not the same. Action scenes are fast, loud, and visible. Suspense builds slowly and happens in the reader’s mind. You can have suspense without violence or chase scenes. What matters is the feeling that something is coming.

If your story jumps from one action scene to the next, without time for tension to grow, the reader may feel tired rather than excited. Suspense needs pacing. Use quieter moments to let fear build.

A ticking clock, a close call, a secret kept too long—these are tools of suspense. They rely on emotion and thought, not just movement.

Mistake 6: Overuse of Cliffhangers

Ending every chapter with a cliffhanger can become predictable. If the reader knows that every chapter will end with a shock, the effect wears off. Suspense needs variety. Sometimes, a quiet moment can be more tense than a dramatic reveal.

Use cliffhangers when they move the story forward. Do not force them. Let some chapters end with a question, a doubt, or a choice. These softer endings still create suspense, but in a more subtle way.

Balance is key. Mix high tension with moments of reflection. This keeps the reader alert and emotionally invested.

Mistake 7: Ignoring the Reader’s Perspective

You must write with the reader’s experience in mind. If the reader gets ahead of the story, suspense fades. If they fall behind, they get lost. The challenge is to give just enough information to keep them curious.

Manage what the reader knows. You can use different points of view, limited knowledge, or unreliable narrators. But do so with care. Avoid tricks that make the reader feel misled. Suspense works best when the reader feels they are part of the story, trying to figure it out.

Test your scenes. Ask what the reader feels at each point. Are they curious? Worried? Surprised? If not, revise to increase the emotional effect.

Conclusion

Writing suspense is about control. You must guide the reader through moments of uncertainty, risk, and anticipation. Avoid giving too much away. Avoid adding shocks without meaning. Build tension through character, stakes, and pacing.

Every scene should serve the story. Every choice should increase the reader’s interest. If you keep the suspense real and grounded, your story will hold attention to the end.

To learn more about narrative technique and improve your writing skills, subscribe to the WriTribe.com newsletter. If this post was useful, share it with other writers or on your social media channels.